METHOD REVIEW REQUEST PACKET / October 2, 2026
Status: public feedback request; no reviewer has accepted or endorsed the work.
Protocol: https://murderbench.com/artifacts/final-study.txt
Frozen configuration: https://murderbench.com/artifacts/full-manifest.json
Exact manifest SHA256: 1c59cefc12edd2878eada536857831a0824b846cd5238b3b0c2449a95f132773
Commit-pinned archive: https://github.com/fastrocket/murderbench/tree/0d74488ecb08823b191873fb80aa2d18f4c7d0a6/plans/freezes/1c59cefc12edd2878eada536857831a0824b846cd5238b3b0c2449a95f132773
Source: https://github.com/fastrocket/murderbench
Overlap audit: https://murderbench.com/artifacts/overlap-audit.txt
Evidence questions:
1. Which exact existing dataset case already tests this paired verified-state change?
2. Does fixed-history constraint updating have useful decision value, or is it
   ordinary instruction following that should be reported only as a diagnostic?
3. Are failed stable controls, invalid outputs and missing partners treated correctly?
4. What counterbalanced rollout or mitigation extension merits funding?
5. Which independent failure cases should test the external state-gate baseline?
Suggested feedback window: October16,2026; this is an invitation, not a commitment.
Respond to linh@ngo.net or the published social invitation. Do not send secrets
or executable attack payloads. Substantive feedback will receive a dated issue
and disposition record; private identities will not be published without consent.

Blinded-label review handoff: https://murderbench.com/artifacts/label-review.txt
Reviewer participation is pending; no completed review is implied.